I've seen NMF props installed on CONUS B-24 trainers also. Do you suppose the one in your photo was a new unit from Depot stock that hadn't been painted originally?
As far as I know, the B-17D props were Natural Metal, as were all th earlier propellors for the B-17 series; I'd bet that whatever airscrew was handy (easily available at hand) at the time was thrown on Number 4 when she needed a propellor change.
That's my best "uneducated inpert" "guesstimate".
Hope it helps!
PS have the B-17B IARCs done and am now working on the B-17C and B-17D ones as I get them.
Warmest regards, best wishes, and Season's Greetings,
Dan Katz
PS - My birthday was 3 days after you posted this! Thanks! (I've only just managed to get back here and am enjoying all the posts that these excellent sleuths, resources/authorities/authors/students [like Mr. Birdsall], and all the other people with very good questions to ask, have been contributing)
This is indeed a nice vintage photo. Perhaps, we can really tell if the prop is unpainted or not if you have another photo. It could be the angle of the photo shoot. B&W photos don't give much detail either. I love to see more of these!
Gentlemen: (Or, rather, Esteemed Sirs:)
To the best of my knowledge, judging by photos I've seen, the B-17B, B-17C, and B-17D propellors and blades were originally in Natural Metal (steel?), as was the prototype B-17E at first.
I can only assume that, since the B-17C, B-17D, and, apparently, also, B-17E, propellors and blades were very similar if not identical, (the prop blades didn't change width along with matching modified cowlings 'til the -F model) that, therefore, spare or salvaged B-17C and B-17D complete propellors, and propellor blades, were standard replacements on the B-17E aircraft here in the States (the aircraft shown may just be from Hendricks!)or Z.I., and this is the probable explanation, at least from what I have seen so far, and the information available to me as of today, May 6, 2010.
I hope this helps!
Warmest regards and best wishes to all (Happy Hindenburg day?),
Dan Katz